« Jesus Walk With MeMainFemininity is Back! »

December 15, 2004

It's Oh So Telling

Never trust any place that markets materials to "boys" and "girlhoods". If there was ever a problem with the uber-headship homeschool Nazi's, it's the sick reductionist objectification of women to mere charicatures, to simply "girlhood". If this isn't sold from the guys perspective, I dunno what is. I call it evil.

Anyways, the Vision Forum folks are just the next in the long line of Enlightenment-American-Presbyterian-Church-Splitting status quo. I'm sure Nick will pipe up and say they've got some good things to say, and I'm sure its there, tucked away, somewhere.

You know, its a funny thing, that speck of white on top of a pile of bird crap...

  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • Ma.gnolia
  • share on facebook

Josiah Q. Roe | By Josiah Roe | 10:39 PM

Comments

Word. Aren't they nearly theonomist too?

Posted by: Evan Donovan at December 16, 2004 12:15 AM

Don't ask me how, but somehow or other my parents got on the Vision Forum mailing list. With the exception of the calligraphy set, the stuff in the "girlhood" collection made me want to vomit (and don't get me started on Elsie Dinsmore--why we should want girls to emulate an abused child with zero self esteem is beyond me).

Posted by: kathryn at December 16, 2004 02:23 AM

Why is this stuff always from the 17th-19th century? Is stereotypical masculinity/femininty impossible in this century or something? If it is, then why would anyone want it? If it's not, what's the deal?

Posted by: ryan at December 16, 2004 07:48 AM

What's also really funny to me, is that on an aesthetic level its like they've managed to transcend kitsch right back into kitsch. I mean, in the 1950's kitsch was all the crap kids toys etc. done up in a colonial or western style. Now they're ripping off the kitsch from that era, generating a whole new level of kitsch.

Anyways, check this video out.

New levels of creepy.

Posted by: JosiahQ at December 16, 2004 09:50 AM

Elsie Dinsmore is such an awesome name. It sounds like a vile street urchin from a Dickens novel. The very vowels suggest "dingy." People should set aside portions of each day to create potential names for new VisionForum characters. Here's mine: Lucius Codwater.

Posted by: mesh at December 16, 2004 10:50 AM

This reminds me of how Douglas Wilson says feminism is the result of ungodly men not doing their jobs. I'm not saying he's wrong, but in order for feminism to rise in the 60's, the 50's--that gleeful, wholesome time of prosperity--had to happen. Isn't this kind of nostalgia asking for the same thing to happen again?

Posted by: Tommy Jolly at December 16, 2004 11:31 AM

Mesh,

Arthur Trumpbottom
Lance Hood
Emily Shuttlecock

Posted by: Phil at December 16, 2004 12:08 PM

Hey Josiah. Looks like you are doing well – so glad. I share your problem with this weird "reductionistic objectification of women." I know a lot of these folks through homeschooling, and it's as if they think the solution to increased secularization is through a time machine, rather than more difficult, complex thinking about how our faith and values can be successfully and relevantly translated in a new time and a new culture. Par exemple: ladiesagainstfeminism.com. It’s interesting, hilarious, and infuriating. By the by, I’m not sure modesty of dress is properly exemplified by 18th century, Jane Austen-esque garb. Was I the ONLY one who noticed all the cleavage in Pride & Prejudice?

Posted by: Ruckus at December 16, 2004 03:34 PM

Cleavage Prejudice would also be a good name.

Posted by: mesh at December 16, 2004 06:23 PM

Ciao, il mio amico! It is me. Though, after a long and exhausting argument with my dear spouse about the merits of keeping one's maiden name, I am now, officially, somethign else. :-(. Email me sometime -- I'd love to hear how you're doing.

Posted by: Ruckus at December 17, 2004 10:21 AM

Post a Comment About "It's Oh So Telling"










Remember personal info?






Email "It's Oh So Telling" to a friend!

Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://chattablogs.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/17327

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference It's Oh So Telling:

MORE ENTRIES

Visit the Irresponsible Journalism Archives for further reading.

Baracky: the Movie

Yo Adrian!

Detroit City Council

probably the one and only time I'll be thankful for the Chattanooga City Council

Aaron Mesh Reviews Chapter 27

ends his chances to guest-speak/lecture at Covenant College

Earth Day Chattanooga

be there

Chattanooga Green Building in the TFP

and a nod to green|spaces

Aaron Mesh Interviews David Gordon Green

fav critic & fav director

About the Music

David Morton & Lou Wamp in the TFP

The Top 25 Songs of 2K7 Mashed

by DJ Earworm

It's Like, A Metaphor

I still don't think the kids got it

Walrus Michael Jackson

you've been hit by a very large smooth criminal

Would You Like to Meet a Republican Congressman?

or a televangelist

U Can't Stop Action-Hero Barack

he even roudhoused kicked Chuck Norris

Once in Jurassic Park Time

Dodson! We've Got Dodson Here!

That Baby Aint Right

clearly, he/she is no stranger to love

Barack Steady

all night long

Barack Will Give You Everything

stuff I can believe in!

What Happens When You Quit Smoking

15 years is a long ways off (14 years, 5 months)

Why Should The Devil Have All The Good Vibrators?

get yours at Book22

The Cowardice of the Media

The enemy of journalism locally is the "Human Interest Story"

Please Consider Running for Mayor

please!