« Marines in IraqMainThe Sopranos »

May 21, 2004

Quick Clarification

After looking over my last post I realize I needed to clarify some things, in fact, REALLY needed to clarify things. I believe:

1. What has occured at Abu Ghraib is wrong
2. Some of what has been reported having occured at Abu Ghraib is evil.
3. Some of what has occured, but by no means all, is frat-boy shennanigans.
4. I want to understand the greater context of the pictures, the who, the what, the where, and the why before making blanket statements and deriving conclusions from events at Abu Ghraib
5. Though probably unintentional the events at Abu Ghraib dig at Arabic/Islamic sexual mores, this does not in ANY extext excuse said actions (you'd have to be a loon to think so)

  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • Ma.gnolia
  • share on facebook

Josiah Q. Roe | By Josiah Roe | 02:52 PM

Comments

Not to jump into the middle of things, but this is a WAR. Different rules apply. Not that they excuse behavior, but the prison abuses are nothing new -- and not exclusive to us.

Perhaps digital photgraphy and lightning-fast media is (finally) giving us a glimpse of how war -- and how people act during it -- has ALWAYS been.

Posted by: Bill Colrus at May 21, 2004 02:56 PM

Post a Comment About "Quick Clarification"










Remember personal info?






Email "Quick Clarification" to a friend!

Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://chattablogs.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/11483

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Quick Clarification:

MORE ENTRIES

Visit the Irresponsible Journalism Archives for further reading.

Baracky: the Movie

Yo Adrian!

Detroit City Council

probably the one and only time I'll be thankful for the Chattanooga City Council

Aaron Mesh Reviews Chapter 27

ends his chances to guest-speak/lecture at Covenant College

Earth Day Chattanooga

be there

Chattanooga Green Building in the TFP

and a nod to green|spaces

Aaron Mesh Interviews David Gordon Green

fav critic & fav director

About the Music

David Morton & Lou Wamp in the TFP

The Top 25 Songs of 2K7 Mashed

by DJ Earworm

It's Like, A Metaphor

I still don't think the kids got it

Walrus Michael Jackson

you've been hit by a very large smooth criminal

Would You Like to Meet a Republican Congressman?

or a televangelist

U Can't Stop Action-Hero Barack

he even roudhoused kicked Chuck Norris

Once in Jurassic Park Time

Dodson! We've Got Dodson Here!

That Baby Aint Right

clearly, he/she is no stranger to love

Barack Steady

all night long

Barack Will Give You Everything

stuff I can believe in!

What Happens When You Quit Smoking

15 years is a long ways off (14 years, 5 months)

Why Should The Devil Have All The Good Vibrators?

get yours at Book22

The Cowardice of the Media

The enemy of journalism locally is the "Human Interest Story"

Please Consider Running for Mayor

please!